18 Reviews

Old Bag of Nails Pub

Mansfield, Ohio
Reviews
Michelle Hritz
19 Jul 2018
REPORT
Nothing special, too much a chain restaurant feel for me but if you just wanted a drink, probably great place to meet friends and cheers.
Christopher Carlsson
11 Jul 2018
REPORT
Great $10 special of a burger and a beer on Sundays ( a kind of adult happy meal ) with an extensive and moderately priced food menu. Beer selection is a bit minimal bar is fairly pedestrian, but larg... Read More
Great $10 special of a burger and a beer on Sundays ( a kind of adult happy meal ) with an extensive and moderately priced food menu. Beer selection is a bit minimal bar is fairly pedestrian, but large seating areas inside and out , lots of TV’s , bar games and such make it an upper end sports bar rather than a cocktail bar. Read Less
Jessica Carr
28 Jun 2018
REPORT
Our regular staff members and managers are outstanding. We are moving out of state and want to take them all with us. Most amazing people we have ever met. They not only know and love us but also our ... Read More
Our regular staff members and managers are outstanding. We are moving out of state and want to take them all with us. Most amazing people we have ever met. They not only know and love us but also our children which makes dining out with children a breeze. Daryle and Trista make us come back time and time again. We love and will miss this place!!!! Read Less
Carla Norris
20 Jun 2018
REPORT
So friendly and great food! Rosie' s most favorite place! Thank you for loving Rosie and making her feel so special!
realdeel13
13 Jun 2018
REPORT
Can't say enough about the ambiance the staff, many IPAS and domestic to choose from. Trying the mussels is a must, doubt if there are better right on the beach.
Shanna Chatraw
6 May 2018
REPORT
Pleasantly surprised by this spot! Wasn’t sure based on photos and location but, the food exceeded my expectations. Prices are fair and the food is delicious. I recommend the mussels and definitely fr... Read More
Pleasantly surprised by this spot! Wasn’t sure based on photos and location but, the food exceeded my expectations. Prices are fair and the food is delicious. I recommend the mussels and definitely fried corn! Read Less
Bryan Clair
6 May 2018
REPORT
The food, service and atmosphere were all awesome.
Robert V
14 Apr 2018
REPORT
Was in town for some racing at Mid-Ohio. Great place with great decor and a great selection of local craft beers. Only issue was my NY strip was slightly overdone. If you're in town for racing and nee... Read More
Was in town for some racing at Mid-Ohio. Great place with great decor and a great selection of local craft beers. Only issue was my NY strip was slightly overdone. If you're in town for racing and need a good place to eat and have a beer, this is it! Read Less
M Motter
11 Feb 2018
REPORT
Been here many times and never had a bad experience. Good food, good service, many choices. They have my favorite, Angry Orchard on tap! My favorite is the all you can eat chili and corn bread thou... Read More
Been here many times and never had a bad experience. Good food, good service, many choices. They have my favorite, Angry Orchard on tap! My favorite is the all you can eat chili and corn bread though it is seasonal and not always available. They make a great Chicken Quasidilla too. Many sandwich choices. Read Less
David Downey
29 Dec 2017
REPORT
I have never been disappointed with a meal here. I usually go for the fish & chips, as I can't recall having better pub-style fish in the area. The fish is soft and tender and portioned well. The onio... Read More
I have never been disappointed with a meal here. I usually go for the fish & chips, as I can't recall having better pub-style fish in the area. The fish is soft and tender and portioned well. The onion rings make for a great appetizer. I have also gotten the Philly cheese steak which did justice to the Philly cheese steak experience. Service has been good and reliable and interior is a warm pub atmosphere and clean/well-maintained. Read Less
Michael W.
9 Dec 2017
REPORT
Had perhaps one of the worst experiences of all time. With a party of 12 and they literally didn't get one order right from the drink orders to the entrées. A total debacle! Took over two hours to get... Read More
Had perhaps one of the worst experiences of all time. With a party of 12 and they literally didn't get one order right from the drink orders to the entrées. A total debacle! Took over two hours to get sorted out and then of course the bills took forever to get let alone paying for and finally getting to leave what had turned into a dining hell. No sight of any kind of management at all. No idea how they stay open. Please avoid!!! Read Less
Brooke Weikle
23 Jul 2017
REPORT
The burger was good but fries were bleh. My mom didn't like her Philly cheese steak either. Server was nice, but ultra slow. We had to wait for napkins and silverware before we could even eat. I had t... Read More
The burger was good but fries were bleh. My mom didn't like her Philly cheese steak either. Server was nice, but ultra slow. We had to wait for napkins and silverware before we could even eat. I had to ask for the check. I prefer my check to be given before I'm even finished eating so that I can leave when I'm done and not have to wait. Read Less
Kalya Smith
20 Jul 2017
REPORT
It was the worst experience I've ever had in a restaurant. Me and my fiance and 1year old went in for dinner. Before we seat down I ask for a high chair for my baby they never bring me one. Don't no... Read More
It was the worst experience I've ever had in a restaurant. Me and my fiance and 1year old went in for dinner. Before we seat down I ask for a high chair for my baby they never bring me one. Don't not get a waitress for about 10minutes no drinks no. Then a group came in 20mins after we did they got drinks before us. He came an took r drink orders but never got me the high chair I asked again for one never came with one so I had to hold my child on my lap.took for ever to bring us r food we took it to go. Bring us the check before we could see r food. Food us so bad over cooked fries was cold did not get my baby food at all. Will never go back there ever again. Read Less
Pauline Meyer
29 Jun 2017
REPORT
Usually like this place. Food is good but service leaves a lot to be desired! Waited and 4 different waitress walked by us and didn't even acknowledge us. But ppl after us come in and get waited on ri... Read More
Usually like this place. Food is good but service leaves a lot to be desired! Waited and 4 different waitress walked by us and didn't even acknowledge us. But ppl after us come in and get waited on right away! So we left and are at Der Dutchmen! 5 stars for them!! Read Less
Gary Cox
25 May 2017
REPORT
Adequate selection of both craft beers and items on the menu. Excellent location and weekend entertainment, makes this a " must give it a try " type of place.
Brittany Montey
23 Apr 2017
REPORT
Hadn't been here in a long time. Got the buffalo chicken wrap and it was delicious. Our server Amber was phenomenal. We will definitely be back.
Jayne E.
26 Mar 2017
REPORT
We are here with a party of 8. Since we hadn't seen each other in awhile, we wanted somewhere that we could sit, eat, then drink and enjoy conversation.We made a reservation and explained our situatio... Read More
We are here with a party of 8. Since we hadn't seen each other in awhile, we wanted somewhere that we could sit, eat, then drink and enjoy conversation.We made a reservation and explained our situation that we were coming for lunch and fellowship. We arrived 10 minutes before our reservation time and immediately seated. Our table was uncomfortably close to the party (child's birthday) behind us. One server told us we could move the table a bit further away after the party on the other side had left, which we did. Our waitress, while not overly personable, was effective. She got our drinks and orders quickly. The blackened fish was good; the seasoning was very uneven with some parts thick with seasoning and other parts with barely any. My steak fries were half steak fries, half regular fries. The pretzel and pickle appetizers were very good.After the meal our plates were cleared and bills immediately handed out. We were never offered refills after our bills. Matter of fact, we had no service of any kind. We were far from leaving and would have had a few more drinks, but we weren't offered beer, tea refills, anything. We sat for at least an hour with no offer of drinks or otherwise. I do not recommend this place for a party looking to spend some time.The worst part of the experience was the restroom. The toilet paper holder was out and there was a large roll setting out almost out of reach. There were no paper towels. There was food fragments all over the floor, which was very slippery. The bathroom had a very strong vomit smell and there was chunks of 'something' on the wall by the toilet. The trash can was fairly empty, so the towels had been low / empty for awhile. I told the other females at the table to avoid that bathroom. It was disgusting.I have been to this same restaurant in Delaware and was underwhelmed. The food is okay, nothing outstanding. I wouldn't choose to return to this location any time soon. Read Less
Troy Z.
4 Jul 2015
REPORT
Went for dinner and had an okay experience. Good enough I would come back, but I still have a few complaints. I got no silverware when my meal came out. It was difficult to get the waiters attention b... Read More
Went for dinner and had an okay experience. Good enough I would come back, but I still have a few complaints. I got no silverware when my meal came out. It was difficult to get the waiters attention because he was in back using the Point Of Service machine. Phone calls for other staff seemed more important than helping me out with my requests. Food was great. Salad was good. Clam chowder was solid (lots of potatoes very little clam). French onion was still good, but had lots of cheese and bread. Would want about half the amount if toppings next time. Still 4 stars. 1 for cleanliness, 1 for edible food, 1 for decent service, 1 for awesome drink prices. No "wow factor" star.Reviewed rating would go down to 3.5 stars, yet ill still give them 4 stars because they actively try. Still understaffed. Again, No silverware with my salad. Then no spook with my soup. Maybe i shoulda just shoved my face in there and eaten like an animal? Place is called old bag of nails. Sounds like farm food served in a rickety barn. Read Less
Photo Gallery
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
Book an Appointment
Online booking unavailable
Please call
(419) 775-5937
625 Lexington Ave # 7
Mansfield Ohio 44907
Business Hours
Monday
Mon
11:00AM-22:00PM
Tuesday
Tue
11:00AM-22:00PM
Wednesday
Wed
11:00AM-22:00PM
Thursday
Thu
11:00AM-22:00PM
Friday
Fri
11:00AM-23:00PM
Saturday
Sat
11:00AM-23:00PM
Sunday
Sun
11:00AM-22:00PM
Is this your business?
CLAIM IT HERE
Incorrect information? Let us know

Old Bag of Nails Pub

Mansfield, Ohio
(18)
625 Lexington Ave # 7
Mansfield Ohio 44907
Monday
11:00AM-22:00PM
Tuesday
11:00AM-22:00PM
Wednesday
11:00AM-22:00PM
Thursday
11:00AM-22:00PM
Friday
11:00AM-23:00PM
Saturday
11:00AM-23:00PM
Sunday
11:00AM-22:00PM
Michelle Hritz
19 Jul 2018
REPORT
Nothing special, too much a chain restaurant feel for me but if you just wanted a drink, probably great place to meet friends and cheers.
Christopher Carlsson
11 Jul 2018
REPORT
Great $10 special of a burger and a beer on Sundays ( a kind of adult happy meal ) with an extensive and moderately priced food menu. Beer selection is a bit minimal bar is fairly pedestrian, but larg... Read More
Great $10 special of a burger and a beer on Sundays ( a kind of adult happy meal ) with an extensive and moderately priced food menu. Beer selection is a bit minimal bar is fairly pedestrian, but large seating areas inside and out , lots of TV’s , bar games and such make it an upper end sports bar rather than a cocktail bar. Read Less
Jessica Carr
28 Jun 2018
REPORT
Our regular staff members and managers are outstanding. We are moving out of state and want to take them all with us. Most amazing people we have ever met. They not only know and love us but also our ... Read More
Our regular staff members and managers are outstanding. We are moving out of state and want to take them all with us. Most amazing people we have ever met. They not only know and love us but also our children which makes dining out with children a breeze. Daryle and Trista make us come back time and time again. We love and will miss this place!!!! Read Less
Carla Norris
20 Jun 2018
REPORT
So friendly and great food! Rosie' s most favorite place! Thank you for loving Rosie and making her feel so special!
realdeel13
13 Jun 2018
REPORT
Can't say enough about the ambiance the staff, many IPAS and domestic to choose from. Trying the mussels is a must, doubt if there are better right on the beach.
Shanna Chatraw
6 May 2018
REPORT
Pleasantly surprised by this spot! Wasn’t sure based on photos and location but, the food exceeded my expectations. Prices are fair and the food is delicious. I recommend the mussels and definitely fr... Read More
Pleasantly surprised by this spot! Wasn’t sure based on photos and location but, the food exceeded my expectations. Prices are fair and the food is delicious. I recommend the mussels and definitely fried corn! Read Less
Bryan Clair
6 May 2018
REPORT
The food, service and atmosphere were all awesome.
Robert V
14 Apr 2018
REPORT
Was in town for some racing at Mid-Ohio. Great place with great decor and a great selection of local craft beers. Only issue was my NY strip was slightly overdone. If you're in town for racing and nee... Read More
Was in town for some racing at Mid-Ohio. Great place with great decor and a great selection of local craft beers. Only issue was my NY strip was slightly overdone. If you're in town for racing and need a good place to eat and have a beer, this is it! Read Less
M Motter
11 Feb 2018
REPORT
Been here many times and never had a bad experience. Good food, good service, many choices. They have my favorite, Angry Orchard on tap! My favorite is the all you can eat chili and corn bread thou... Read More
Been here many times and never had a bad experience. Good food, good service, many choices. They have my favorite, Angry Orchard on tap! My favorite is the all you can eat chili and corn bread though it is seasonal and not always available. They make a great Chicken Quasidilla too. Many sandwich choices. Read Less
David Downey
29 Dec 2017
REPORT
I have never been disappointed with a meal here. I usually go for the fish & chips, as I can't recall having better pub-style fish in the area. The fish is soft and tender and portioned well. The onio... Read More
I have never been disappointed with a meal here. I usually go for the fish & chips, as I can't recall having better pub-style fish in the area. The fish is soft and tender and portioned well. The onion rings make for a great appetizer. I have also gotten the Philly cheese steak which did justice to the Philly cheese steak experience. Service has been good and reliable and interior is a warm pub atmosphere and clean/well-maintained. Read Less
Michael W.
9 Dec 2017
REPORT
Had perhaps one of the worst experiences of all time. With a party of 12 and they literally didn't get one order right from the drink orders to the entrées. A total debacle! Took over two hours to get... Read More
Had perhaps one of the worst experiences of all time. With a party of 12 and they literally didn't get one order right from the drink orders to the entrées. A total debacle! Took over two hours to get sorted out and then of course the bills took forever to get let alone paying for and finally getting to leave what had turned into a dining hell. No sight of any kind of management at all. No idea how they stay open. Please avoid!!! Read Less
Brooke Weikle
23 Jul 2017
REPORT
The burger was good but fries were bleh. My mom didn't like her Philly cheese steak either. Server was nice, but ultra slow. We had to wait for napkins and silverware before we could even eat. I had t... Read More
The burger was good but fries were bleh. My mom didn't like her Philly cheese steak either. Server was nice, but ultra slow. We had to wait for napkins and silverware before we could even eat. I had to ask for the check. I prefer my check to be given before I'm even finished eating so that I can leave when I'm done and not have to wait. Read Less
Kalya Smith
20 Jul 2017
REPORT
It was the worst experience I've ever had in a restaurant. Me and my fiance and 1year old went in for dinner. Before we seat down I ask for a high chair for my baby they never bring me one. Don't no... Read More
It was the worst experience I've ever had in a restaurant. Me and my fiance and 1year old went in for dinner. Before we seat down I ask for a high chair for my baby they never bring me one. Don't not get a waitress for about 10minutes no drinks no. Then a group came in 20mins after we did they got drinks before us. He came an took r drink orders but never got me the high chair I asked again for one never came with one so I had to hold my child on my lap.took for ever to bring us r food we took it to go. Bring us the check before we could see r food. Food us so bad over cooked fries was cold did not get my baby food at all. Will never go back there ever again. Read Less
Pauline Meyer
29 Jun 2017
REPORT
Usually like this place. Food is good but service leaves a lot to be desired! Waited and 4 different waitress walked by us and didn't even acknowledge us. But ppl after us come in and get waited on ri... Read More
Usually like this place. Food is good but service leaves a lot to be desired! Waited and 4 different waitress walked by us and didn't even acknowledge us. But ppl after us come in and get waited on right away! So we left and are at Der Dutchmen! 5 stars for them!! Read Less
Gary Cox
25 May 2017
REPORT
Adequate selection of both craft beers and items on the menu. Excellent location and weekend entertainment, makes this a " must give it a try " type of place.
Brittany Montey
23 Apr 2017
REPORT
Hadn't been here in a long time. Got the buffalo chicken wrap and it was delicious. Our server Amber was phenomenal. We will definitely be back.
Jayne E.
26 Mar 2017
REPORT
We are here with a party of 8. Since we hadn't seen each other in awhile, we wanted somewhere that we could sit, eat, then drink and enjoy conversation.We made a reservation and explained our situatio... Read More
We are here with a party of 8. Since we hadn't seen each other in awhile, we wanted somewhere that we could sit, eat, then drink and enjoy conversation.We made a reservation and explained our situation that we were coming for lunch and fellowship. We arrived 10 minutes before our reservation time and immediately seated. Our table was uncomfortably close to the party (child's birthday) behind us. One server told us we could move the table a bit further away after the party on the other side had left, which we did. Our waitress, while not overly personable, was effective. She got our drinks and orders quickly. The blackened fish was good; the seasoning was very uneven with some parts thick with seasoning and other parts with barely any. My steak fries were half steak fries, half regular fries. The pretzel and pickle appetizers were very good.After the meal our plates were cleared and bills immediately handed out. We were never offered refills after our bills. Matter of fact, we had no service of any kind. We were far from leaving and would have had a few more drinks, but we weren't offered beer, tea refills, anything. We sat for at least an hour with no offer of drinks or otherwise. I do not recommend this place for a party looking to spend some time.The worst part of the experience was the restroom. The toilet paper holder was out and there was a large roll setting out almost out of reach. There were no paper towels. There was food fragments all over the floor, which was very slippery. The bathroom had a very strong vomit smell and there was chunks of 'something' on the wall by the toilet. The trash can was fairly empty, so the towels had been low / empty for awhile. I told the other females at the table to avoid that bathroom. It was disgusting.I have been to this same restaurant in Delaware and was underwhelmed. The food is okay, nothing outstanding. I wouldn't choose to return to this location any time soon. Read Less
Troy Z.
4 Jul 2015
REPORT
Went for dinner and had an okay experience. Good enough I would come back, but I still have a few complaints. I got no silverware when my meal came out. It was difficult to get the waiters attention b... Read More
Went for dinner and had an okay experience. Good enough I would come back, but I still have a few complaints. I got no silverware when my meal came out. It was difficult to get the waiters attention because he was in back using the Point Of Service machine. Phone calls for other staff seemed more important than helping me out with my requests. Food was great. Salad was good. Clam chowder was solid (lots of potatoes very little clam). French onion was still good, but had lots of cheese and bread. Would want about half the amount if toppings next time. Still 4 stars. 1 for cleanliness, 1 for edible food, 1 for decent service, 1 for awesome drink prices. No "wow factor" star.Reviewed rating would go down to 3.5 stars, yet ill still give them 4 stars because they actively try. Still understaffed. Again, No silverware with my salad. Then no spook with my soup. Maybe i shoulda just shoved my face in there and eaten like an animal? Place is called old bag of nails. Sounds like farm food served in a rickety barn. Read Less
Is this your business?
CLAIM IT HERE
Incorrect information? Let us know